Short answer first, because that is what I wanted when I started looking. If your nose is stuffy at night and you want the simplest thing that gets air moving, Breathe Right Extra Strength nasal strips are the easier habit to keep. You press one on, you peel it off in the morning, and nothing goes inside your nostrils. If you have tried the strips and quit because the adhesive itched or the ends curled up before two in the morning, an internal nasal dilator is worth the ten minutes it takes to learn to use one. That is the comparison in two sentences. Everything after this is the detail that made me go back and forth for six weeks before I decided to keep both in the nightstand drawer.
I am not a doctor and I am not going to write this like one. I am 62, I live in Colorado Springs, and I have been a loud snorer for about 20 years. My wife Linda is a light sleeper. A home sleep test a few years back showed moderate obstructive sleep apnea, and I have slept with a CPAP machine and a nasal pillow mask for about three years now. Sleep apnea is a medical condition. It needs a sleep study and a doctor, and no strip or plastic insert is a treatment for it. What I am talking about here is the smaller, everyday thing: getting air through your nose so you can settle down, and so the person next to you can settle down too. Linda noticed a difference in me long before I noticed it in myself.
| Breathe Right Extra Strength | Internal nasal dilator | |
|---|---|---|
| What it is | An adhesive strip worn on the outside of the nose | A small reusable device that sits inside the nostrils |
| Anything inside the nose | Nothing. It works from the outside | A device in each nostril |
| Sizing | One strip, no fitting, no sizes to pick | Sold in sizes, and the wrong size does very little |
| Cost over a year | You buy a box, you use it up, you buy another | Buy once, rinse, reuse |
| Adhesive on skin | Glue on your nose every night, which can itch | No adhesive anywhere |
| Staying put until morning | Edges can lift on oily or sweaty skin | Stays where you put it until you take it out |
| Cleaning and upkeep | None. Peel and toss | Rinse after each use and let it dry |
| Travel and packing | Flat, light, disposable, goes in a jacket pocket | Small, but it needs rinsing and a place to dry |
| Dry winter air | Works the same on the driest night | A dry nose can make an inserted device uncomfortable |
| Best for | Back sleepers who want zero fuss | Side sleepers who roll and peel strips loose |
Where Breathe Right Wins
The strip wins on simplicity, and simplicity is not a small thing at eleven at night when you are tired and your nose is plugged. You peel the backing, press it across the bridge of your nose, and you are done. No sizing, no pinching, no figuring out which end points which way. The box I keep in the drawer holds 26 strips, the whole box measures about 3 by 1 by 4.13 inches and weighs 1.4 ounces, and it disappears into a shaving kit or a jacket pocket. When I drive out of state to see my kids, I take the box and nothing else. No rinse cup, no little case, no standing at a hotel sink at midnight trying to remember where I set something down. Last October I drove to Kansas to see my son and stayed two nights in a motel outside Salina. The box rode in the door pocket the whole way. Both nights I pressed one on, slept, peeled it off in the morning, and dropped it in the wastebasket by the bed. A dilator would have meant rinsing it in a motel bathroom sink, setting it on a washcloth to dry, and hoping housekeeping did not sweep it into a trash bag while I was at breakfast. That is not a hard job. It is just one more job, and on the road I would rather have fewer of them.
It also wins on what is not in your nose. Some nights my nose is already raw from the dry air we get here at this altitude, and the last thing I want is something pressing on the inside of it. The strip pulls from the outside instead. The extra strength version uses flexible spring-like bands that the company describes as 50 percent stronger than the original strips, and the adhesive is made for sensitive skin, hypoallergenic and non-porous. My skin reacts to ordinary bandages, and I can wear these most nights without trouble, though not every single night, which I will get to. And there is the trash can. A strip goes in it. There is no rinsing, no drying on a paper towel, no wondering whether the thing on the nightstand is clean. I have also fallen asleep on the couch with one on and forgotten about it until Linda raised her eyebrows at me over dinner.
Where Internal Nasal Dilators Win
A box of strips runs out. That is the deal you make with anything disposable, and over a year it adds up in a way a reusable device does not. An internal dilator is a one-time purchase, and after that the only thing it costs you is the thirty seconds it takes to rinse it in the morning. If you are going to wear something every single night for years, that math is worth doing. The other place the dilator wins outright is adhesive. If your skin reacts, or if you have ever pulled a strip off in the morning and taken a layer of skin with it, you already understand why some people give up on strips entirely and never go back. Here is the other thing about a consumable you use every single night for years: it becomes furniture. You stop noticing you are buying it, and then one day you look in the drawer and realize you have bought the same cardboard box over and over. I am not going to pretend that decides it, because it does not. But if you are the kind of person who resents a recurring errand, the reusable option deletes that errand permanently.
The dilator also stays where you put it. Strips depend on clean, dry, oil-free skin, and my nose does not always cooperate. On a warm night, or after I wash my face with something that leaves a film behind, the ends lift. Once an end lifts, the strip is doing half its job and I can feel it doing half its job. A dilator does not care about oil or sweat. It sits inside and stays there until you reach in and take it out, which means side sleepers who roll over and press their face into a pillow get more out of one than out of a strip. Linda could tell you which nights I rolled.
If you want the version with nothing inside your nose, start here
Breathe Right Extra Strength strips press on from the outside, come 26 to a box, and need no rinsing, no sizing and no case. The one I keep buying.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →What Six Weeks of Switching Taught Me
I did this the dumb way, which is usually the way that teaches me something. I put the strips in the top drawer and the dilator on the nightstand and I alternated weeks. First week strips, second week the insert, and so on, with a couple of nights of neither when I fell asleep on the couch watching a ballgame. What I found is that the first three nights with a dilator felt strange in a way I could not argue myself out of. There is something in your nose. Your body knows it is there. By night four I stopped noticing, and by the end of that first week I was putting it in without thinking about it.
The second thing I learned is that fit matters more than anything anyone says about dilators online. The wrong size does almost nothing, and you will swear the whole category is useless based on one bad fit. I sneezed mine across the bathroom once, which Linda found funnier than I did. Strips have no equivalent problem. There is one strip, it goes on your nose, and that is the entire fitting process. If you are the kind of person who does not want to think about a purchase twice, that alone might settle it for you. I ordered the middle size first because the listing said it fit most adults, and it was too small to do much of anything. The next size up was the one that worked. That is two orders, two waits, and about ten days of walking around thinking dilators were a waste of money, all over a fit issue that says nothing about whether they work.
The third thing is the one nobody writes about. Neither of these fixed my snoring on its own. What they did was make the nights when my nose was plugged less miserable, and cut down the dry mouth I get from sleeping with my mouth open. My CPAP machine is what handles the apnea. The strip or the dilator is what handles the stuffy nose that makes the mask harder to settle into. Once I stopped expecting one device to do the other's job, I stopped being annoyed with both of them.
Six weeks, two drawers, one conclusion: the strip is easier, the dilator is cheaper, and neither one is a treatment for sleep apnea.
The Dry Bedroom Problem
Colorado is dry, and our bedroom is drier, because the heat runs from October into April and pulls whatever moisture was in the air right out of it. That matters for this comparison more than it would somewhere humid. Dry air makes my nose raw, and a raw nose is a nose that does not want something new inserted into it. On the worst weeks of winter I reach for the strip, because it works from the outside and the adhesive is made for sensitive skin. In July, when the air is softer, I reach for the dilator without thinking about it. I remember one night in January, the week the furnace ran without shutting off, when I woke at three in the morning with my tongue stuck to the roof of my mouth. I had put the dilator in at ten. My nose was fine. My throat was the problem, and dry air was the cause. The next night I went back to a strip, filled the humidifier on the dresser, and slept through to Linda's alarm. That is not a scientific result. It is just what happened in one bedroom in Colorado in January.
If you live somewhere damp, or you run a humidifier, or your nose is not the sensitive part of your face, you may never notice this. But if you wake up with a dry mouth and a sore nose from November through March, the strip is the gentler of the two options, and that is worth knowing before you spend anything. I keep a glass of water on the nightstand either way. It has not fixed the dry air, but it has cut down how often I wake up feeling like I slept in a clothes dryer.
Who Should Buy Which
Buy the strips if you want the least amount of thought per night. You do not want to size anything, you do not want to rinse anything, you travel, you sleep on your back, and your skin tolerates adhesive. You want to open a box, use one, throw it away, and not think about it again until the box is empty. That is most people, honestly. It is also the version I would hand to somebody who has never tried either thing, because there is no learning curve at all.
Buy an internal dilator if you have already tried strips and quit. If the adhesive itched, if the ends lifted every night, if you roll onto your side and press your face into the pillow, or if you are simply tired of buying a consumable forever, the dilator solves those specific problems. Go into it knowing you may need to try a size or two, and that the first few nights will feel odd. That is normal and it passes.
And one more time, because it matters more than anything else in this article. If Linda had not noticed pauses in my breathing, I would still be snoring through the wall and assuming I was just a loud sleeper. If you snore, or your partner has seen you stop and start again, get the sleep study. Do that before you buy either of these. A strip and a dilator are comfort items. Your airway is not a comfort item.
The one I keep restocking, three years in
Breathe Right Extra Strength: 26 strips, about the size of a deck of cards, nothing to clean and nothing to lose. If your nose is the problem at bedtime, this is the place I would start.
Amazon Check Today's Price on Amazon →